Are We Making People Too Comfortable at Work?

About 25 years ago, when I was still pretty new to financial services, I agreed to run a public course for financial advisers on understanding their clients’ personality profiles.

I’d run the course before, but always in-house with people I knew. That felt easy enough. Familiar faces, familiar environment, and no real fear that someone in the back row was about to cross their arms and decide I was talking complete nonsense.

But the public course felt different.

Cue the self doubt

I imagined a room of advisers who were older than me, more experienced than me, and very established in the industry. Cue the self-doubt.

I was absolutely convinced at least one of them was going to think, “What is this woo-woo rubbish and who is this woman telling us about personality profiles?”

So I prepared like my life depended on it.

I knew the content backwards. I thought through every possible question. I rehearsed how I’d explain the practical value of it, because I was determined nobody was going to catch me wobbling.

And then I ran the course.

Nobody heckled me. Nobody told me I was full of it. Nobody exposed me as the inexperienced fraud I had temporarily decided I was.

In fact, it went really well.

And I remember coming away thinking, “Seriously? THAT was what I was so worried about?!”

That experience probably taught me more than running another ten comfortable in-house sessions ever would have.

When support becomes rescuing

Which is why I sometimes wonder whether we’ve become a little too good at removing discomfort for people at work.

Someone says they’re nervous about presenting, so we don’t make them present. They’re not quite explaining something well in a meeting, so the manager takes over and explains it for them. They don’t feel ready for more responsibility, so we take on all the harder tasks ourselves.

And yes, sometimes that is exactly the right thing to do. But sometimes I think we’re rescuing people from the very thing that might help them grow.

I definitely did not feel ready for that room 25 years ago. My internal monologue had built a very strong case for why I shouldn’t be there.

Turns out, my internal monologue was full of crap.

Discomfort isn’t the same as being unsupported

That doesn’t mean people should be thrown in the deep end with no support and told to “build resilience”. That’s just lazy management dressed up as development.

But good leadership isn’t always about making people feel comfortable either.

Sometimes it’s about knowing someone is capable of more, giving them the support they need, and then resisting the urge to jump in and save them the second they look nervous.

Confidence usually comes afterwards

Our confidence is usually built during and after the thing, not before it.

And sometimes the push we resent in the moment is exactly the push we’re grateful for later.

DCsig

Previous Post
5 ELK is proud to support the BOMS community

Related Articles

The Spirit of Bayanihan

One of the most talked-about pieces of art in 5 ELK HQ is a painting by Filipino artist Ruel Rosello depicting the local tradition of bayanihan. The scene shows a…